Our Story Welcome to High Street Bagels – Freshly Made Every Day
At High Street Bagels, we are passionate about delivering the best bagels in Sayville, NY. Located at 217 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, our bagel shop is a local favorite known for its freshly baked, hand-rolled bagels and delicious spreads. Whether you're craving a classic bagel with cream cheese or a hearty bagel sandwich, we’ve got you covered.
Our Bagel-Making Tradition
At High Street Bagels, we stick to the traditional bagel-making process. Our bagels are hand-rolled, boiled, and then baked to perfection. This process gives them a crispy crust and a soft, chewy center that bagel lovers crave. We believe in using only the finest ingredients — no preservatives, no shortcuts — just authentic, fresh flavors in every bite.
High Street Bagels Our Menu
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Piled with shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, surimi.
Maple honey turkey bacon melted Vermont cheddar cheese honey mustard on a hero
Hot roost beef melted mozzarella on a roll
Roast beef jalapeno pepper jack cheese lettuce tomato onions horseradish sauce on a hero
Hot roast beef melted provolone Russian dressing on a hero
Roasted eggplant tomato mozzarella jalapeno on a roll
Roast beef bacon mated cheddar BBQ sauce on a hero
Bologna American with mayo or mustard on roll
Breaded chicken cutlet American cheese bacon with Russian dressing on a roll
Corned beef Swiss 1000 island grilled marbled rye
Hot pastrami mustard marbled rye
Roast beef ham turkey cheese lettuce tomato hero
Ham genoa salami pepperoni lettuce tomato onion oil vinegar
Shaved beef grilled with onions peppers smothered with cheese on hero
Fried chicken lettuce tomato bacon cheddar honey mustard BBQ sauce pretzel bun
Grilled chicken bacon Swiss lettuce tomato yellow BBQ sauce brioche roll
Grilled chicken peppers onion jack cheddar cheese grilled tortilla
half pounder
Lettuce tomatoes onions fries or rings
half pounder
Half Pounder
half pounder
Half Pounder
Eggs onions ham American cheese Consuming raw or undercooked meat shellfish or fresh eggs may increase
Eggs home fries bacon Swiss jalapeno peppers Consuming raw or undercooked meat shellfish or fresh
Eggs mushrooms grilled onions peppers Consuming raw or undercooked meat shellfish or fresh eggs
Eggs whites spinach Swiss cheese onions Consuming raw or undercooked meat shellfish or fresh
Eggs peppers ham bacon onions Consuming raw or undercooked meat shellfish or fresh eggs may
Red roasted peppers cucumber pepperoni kalamata olives radish tomatoes red onions feta cheese
Red roasted peppers spinach fresh mozzarella cheese salt pepper basil pesto spread
Hummus cucumber tomato red onion Swiss cheese cheddar cheese
Sauteed mushrooms caramelized onions sauteed spinach with tofu spread
Avocado apple slices spinach honey mustard salt pepper
High Street Bagels Our Gallery
